Sunderland’s Greatest Homegrown Forwards: The Pre-War Icons

Sunderland’s Greatest Homegrown Forwards: The Pre-War Icons.

Part two of this historical series will cover legendary names such as Gurney, Gallacher, and Carter!

Part two follows the same criteria as our assessment of Sunderland’s homegrown post-war footballers, determining whether we’ve produced any players who have scored more than Gary Rowell’s 103 goals for the club.

Just as Kevin Phillips, Marco Gabbiadini, Brian Clough, and Len Shackleton were barred from joining the club, so are some well-known pre-war players like Charlie Buchan (signed from Arsenal), Dave Halliday (signed from Dundee), and Arthur Bridgett (signed from Stoke).
So, who is left to consider from a time when Sunderland won six league titles, an FA Cup, and was regarded as one of the best clubs in the country?


Raich Carter

278 appearances, 128 goals

Carter is one player that rose through the ranks at Sunderland and scored more goals than Rowell did.

Carter, born in Hendon, is widely regarded as one of Sunderland’s best players. He won the league and FA Cup as captain, and he also represented Sunderland and England as a schoolboy.

When he left school at the age of fourteen, he did not immediately join for Sunderland. In fact, he turned them down on the recommendation of his guardian (his uncle after his father’s death) because he wanted the young Carter to acquire a craft.

As a result, he began working as an apprentice electrician while also playing for an amateur team.

He signed amateur forms for Sunderland in 1931, at the age of seventeen, and also had a trial with Leicester City, which turned him down.

He eventually signed as a professional for Sunderland. Can this rule Carter out? It almost feels like heresy to do so, but I’ll leave it to others to decide.

Comments are closed, but trackbacks and pingbacks are open.